Here's how this goes. Below is a list of a bunch of things that either have no real proof to support their existence, or things that people refuse to believe in for whatever reason. You guys can copy the list, put it into your comment, and place a tally next to what you believe in. I do not want an explanation of your choices. The list in this comment will be everybody's template. I will place another right after that will be used for me to place everyone's tally. In other words, the second list of this thread is the one that will be updated with everyone's beliefs.

If, for whatever reason, you want your beliefs to be secret, you can PM me (I don't squeal) or just not partake in this activity at all. BE SURE TO USE TALLIES! It makes it a lot less confusing for me. The second chart will use numbers, but please just mark down tallies as if you are the first person to take the poll.

BELIEF CHART

A Higher Deity:
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs:
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:

Edited 9/8/2015 00:16:48

CUMULATIVE BELIEF CHART

Number of Takers: 11


A Higher Deity: 8
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives: 2
Ghosts/Spirits: 4
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):5
Kraken: 4
Leviathan/Sea Serpents: 3
It's Not Butter: 4
JFK Assassination Conspiracy: 2
9/11 inside job: 4
Kennedy/Monroe Affair: 2
Pyramids Built by Aliens: 1
Aliens: 7
Chupacabra:
Mothman: 1
King Arthur and Camelot: 3
Dragons: 4
Dinosaurs: 9
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America: 3
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena): 1
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group): 1
Donald Trump's Hair: 4
Area 51 Conspiracy: 6
Magic: 2
Atlantis: 4
Zombies: 2
da Vinci Code: 2
Roswell: 4

Edited 9/10/2015 19:29:58

A Higher Deity: /
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits: /
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens: /
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs: /
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair: /
Area 51 Conspiracy: /
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell: /

(Wasn't sure what exactly you wanted us to use for tallies, so I put down slashes. Hope that works)

Edit: I do not know why that double posted. Many apologies.

Edited 9/8/2015 02:01:00

No worries. Yeah, slashes and capital i's would work great.

Add on to the list please

CUMULATIVE BELIEF CHART

A Higher Deity: 1
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives: 1
Ghosts/Spirits: 1
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing): 1
Kraken: 1
Leviathan/Sea Serpents: 1
It's Not Butter: 1
JFK Assassination Conspiracy: 1
9/11 inside job: 1
Kennedy/Monroe Affair: 11
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens: 11
Chupacabra:
Mothman: 1
King Arthur and Camelot: 1
Dragons: 1
Dinosaurs: 11
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America: 1
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena): 1
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group): 1
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy: 11
Magic: 1 (Just science we don't understand)
Atlantis: 11
Zombies:
da Vinci Code: 1
Roswell: 1

Ben, you should just put a single "1" just to show me what you believe in, rather, use the clean slate.

What do you mean by "add on to the list?"

Edited 9/8/2015 02:08:47

A Higher Deity:I
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:I
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:I
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:I
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs:I
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:I
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:

I will count acknowledgment of possibilities as a full tally, but thank you for clarifying.

A Higher Deity:
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):+
Kraken:+
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:+
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:+
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs:+
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell: +

I didn't put this event on the poll, since I think it's more of a local thing, but has anyone heard of the Kecksburg, PA incident in 1965?

A Higher Deity: +
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:+
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing): +
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:+
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:+
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:+
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:+
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs:+
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:+ (who knows what they had cooking up in those labs down there)
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy:+
Magic:+
Atlantis:+
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:+

Edited 9/8/2015 03:08:19

A Higher Deity:+
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):+
Kraken:+
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:+
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:+
Aliens:+
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:+
Dragons:+
Dinosaurs:+
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:+
Roswell:

A Higher Deity:+
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs:+
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:/
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:

Not much a chart.

It's more of a poll, but I already created it before I realized my mistake. While you are here, why don't you participate?

Edited 9/8/2015 11:31:05

A Higher Deity:
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):
Kraken:
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job: /
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens: /
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:
Dinosaurs: /
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair: /
Area 51 Conspiracy: /
Magic:
Atlantis:
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:

A Higher Deity:/
Loch Ness Monster:
Bigfoot and Relatives:
Ghosts/Spirits:/
Bloody Mary (not the British Bitch):
Megalodon (Currently existing):/
Kraken:/
Leviathan/Sea Serpents:/
It's Not Butter:
JFK Assassination Conspiracy:
9/11 inside job:
Kennedy/Monroe Affair:
Pyramids Built by Aliens:
Aliens:
Chupacabra:
Mothman:
King Arthur and Camelot:
Dragons:/
Dinosaurs:/
The Giant-*ss Snake in South America:/
Vampires:
Werewolves:
Werebears:
Nandi Bear (Super Hyena):
Black Panthers (the cryptid, not stupid group):
Donald Trump's Hair:
Area 51 Conspiracy:
Magic:/(making my people disappear mysteriously is magical:D)
Atlantis:/
Zombies:
da Vinci Code:
Roswell:

Updated with current count.