@Chris: Why not have a box come up after the game (like it does already), but have an option to rate the template you just played (like you can currently rate the map). Then people could keep rating the template after each time playing it.
The problem with this seems clear:
1. Every player has the same template saved with different IDs, so it's basically impossible to make it consistent for how warlight is coded
2. That could be cool, but not for deciding which templates should be played on the Ladder since any player can vote on any template, and we don't want diplo templates on the Ladder i suppose
3. If you can only vote the templates that are already on the RT Ladder, then you can only vote templates OUT of the ladder, you can't vote any template IN.
@Mike: And templates should be updated at specific dates (example every 2 months ?) as I doubt Fizzer will check daily when a template is out of the selection for the benefit of another one everyday.
Fizzer doesn't have to check anything if it's all automated
@Ollie: Some people are just not skilled enough to reach a 1500+ rating but do like to play the ladder. Should they not have the right to vote? I would rather say something like at least finished 20 games or currently ranked.
Yeah I said 1500+ because it takes roughly 10-15 games on average to get there, 20 games finished are a good parameter too!