We are near the end of this year and I think more clans have fallen than the last(-I may be wrong too). Total collapse/losing more players to other clans(let's just say 6+ as of now) is what I consider as limit to put a clan as a fallen clan.

Many clans have taken players from these fallen clans, becoming stronger and larger which can be seen as rise of clans, along with few other clans which are on the rise, starting from scratch.

Then there are stable clans, which have come from large inactive player base to active players too;

Is activity the only reason for all these three types of clans?

Edited 10/19/2017 13:43:54

https://www.warlight.net/Forum/262098-edges-clan-rankings?Offset=30

according to this post, CORP and Masters are the only steady clans. Take that, all other clans!

edit: and GG too, but they're in a league slightly below us and Masters :(

Edited 10/22/2017 21:16:48

Can't take the ratings super serious when they call Andy the best Lynx, followed by Rento and Hades, and AG.

Timon is easily the best Lynx. I'd put Rento well ahead of Hades and AG as well. Rento vs. Andy is more of a debate in my eyes, I think both are clearly better than Hades or AG, and both worse than timon.

Edited 10/21/2017 23:06:30

check the date of the tread. timon was not in lynx at that time also ag is not in lynx anymore, so that could also have been a hint

Edited 10/21/2017 23:13:41

Timon was absolutely in Lynx in May. He's been in Lynx for over a year.

Edited 10/21/2017 23:25:39

Before i start, i want to explain my rankings. I didn't took inactive players into account. I didn't took alt accounts into account. I didn't took players like timon into consideration for any clan, since his main is in the great Fizzer Appreciation Group.

also he played for apex in cl 8, but i guess he was in lynx otherwise you would not be right

CL8 was not May, 2017, it was June, 2016. You're using someone playing for Apex in 2016 as evidence of what clan they were in in 11 months later?

"Before i start, i want to explain my rankings. I didn't took inactive players into account. I didn't took alt accounts into account. I didn't took players like timon into consideration for any clan, since his main is in the great Fizzer Appreciation Group"

That's fine, I didn't see that till now, but to claim he wasn't in Lynx a mere 5 months ago is totally wrong.

Edited 10/22/2017 02:53:11

Also ONE is underrated imo in that forum as well as turtles being overrated. Albeit it was harder to see that back then.

Hopefully by this time next year, I can have this clan off the ground.

CL8 was not May, 2017, it was June, 2016. You're using someone playing for Apex in 2016 as evidence of what clan they were in in 11 months later?

CL8 started in june 2016, it did not end in june 2016. CL8 divistion a ended in deceber 2016.

I don't use it for evidence were some one was 11 months later i did only write it since you stated that

He's been in Lynx for over a year.

but to claim he wasn't in Lynx a mere 5 months ago is totally wrong.

he has many accounts, and since you cant have a player severeal places in a ranking you need to pin down a main.

Edited 10/22/2017 09:21:53

Timon wasn't in Lynx , If I remember correctly him moving his account into Lynx roughly a few months ago

But of course the best guy to answer this is the man himself.

That's fine, I didn't see that till now, but to claim he wasn't in Lynx a mere 5 months ago is totally wrong.

I don't even know if he was in Lynx 5 months ago or not with an alt, but tbh that doesn't matter.

One thing intrigues me through. How do u think u can talk about those rankings when u weren't on your own here 5 months ago and even many more months prior that date? Why are u even trying to debate on it, when u clearly have a lack of knowledge about that time frame?

1. Masters (steady)
3. GG (steady)
19. CORP (steady)

Though the steady is compared with the clan ranking, it is not nice to ignore GG Ox ;)

I don't have a lack of knowledge about what I posted. At all.

Why assume I have no knowledge?

timon was in lynx over a year ago, before my hiatus began.

Proof:

https://web.archive.org/web/20170412014350/https://www.warlight.net/Clans/?ID=73 That shows him in Lynx on April 12th.

https://web.archive.org/web/20160818190630/https://www.warlight.net/Clans/?ID=73 That shows him in Lynx August 18th, of last year.

Maybe don't just assume I have no idea what I'm talking about. I'm vocal, and opinionated, but I'm not a dumbass.

"But of course the best guy to answer this is the man himself."

Nope, people can misremember, as you just did.

The best way to check would be to find forum posts regarding his joining, or checking the archived copies of the page to see when he joined. Those are infallible, human memory is not.

"it is not nice to ignore GG Ox ;)"

Yes it is. The alternative is much ruder.

Edited 10/22/2017 14:59:39

I want to finish this dumb discussion regarding since when I was a member of Lynx. I checked old mails in my inbox.
21.07.2016: I joined Lynx with the account which is currently in FAG.
9.07.2017: I joined Lynx with this account (which was previously in FAG) and joined FAG with the account that was previously in Lynx.

Please get back on the topic.

That sorts that ^

For me the clans that have gone up recently would be, SNinja with a few new recruits but it's still strange how they are WGs sister clan. VIW are recruiting hard but member rentention is poor so.. They are improving I would say. Nobody else really worth noting.

Clans declining lately.. Turtles maybe with a few inactives and stuff. Although they got 2 new recruits Laith + Tian0 it doesn't replace the quality right now. Maybe.

This is just lately not really a year analysis.

Although my conclusion is the clans are overall on a decrease due to too many clans but not enough members to adequately fill the clans.

I'm vocal, and opinionated, but I'm not a dumbass.

perhaps i misunderstand something because i not a native speaker, but is opinionated and dumbass not somewhat related. the opinionated person have very strong opinions and refuse to accept that they may be wrong, that would mean that they are often wrong about things and therefore not very smart?

Edited 10/22/2017 20:50:09

That seems more like a modern reinterpretation of what opinionated originally meant.

The words origins date back to the 1600's, it being used as a pejorative and having negative connotations is a more recent interpretation.

I was absolutely not claiming that I refuse to acknowledge when I am wrong, or that I continue to hold an opinion even once it has been proven to be wrong. I moreso meant that I tend to be vocal when it comes to voicing my opinions.

I feel far too many people are afraid to be wrong, or they are afraid they might offend others, so they remain silent rather than speaking.

ok, my association was that it might come from opinio = to believe, that being in opposition to knowing something

The real question is whether Warlight has been the same since Poon Squad's decline.