Wow, sometimes the dumbest answers are the right ones. This feels like a cheat to be honest xd

It's a disinformation riddle. Often people get caught up in the wording. That's the trap. The idea is to ignore the riddle and answer the question.

berdan131 took the "thinkin outside the box" approach and won his freedom.

However, there is one item on the list that would help you get off the island. Someone almost had it, but not quite.

Clue: Why would I mention a porno magazine, when I could have simply stated, a magazine?
What about the porno mag gets you off the island?