That makes no sense...

Woho, i got a Fanboy :)

Ok, time to analyze the raw data we've received til yet:

Suspect #1: Tactical Incurison
I agree with JSA's suspicion on Tactical Incursion. He just jumped on the bandwagon twice no, not giving a real reason why

Suspect #2: Kantos
Bandwagon on MMB, random-votes C-17? Makes no sense at all (His vote was in front of C-17's)

Suspect #3: C-17
Bandwagons on bdh-voting, no discussion at all


Suspect #4: HHH
Bandwagons on bdh, no discussion

Suspect #5: bdh
Weird behaviour on day 1

Suspect #6?: Me?
To please rento, i list myself aswell, as he gave some thoughts that may make sense. Yes, making the MMB-lynch fixed wasn't the smartest i've done this game so far, i just really wanted to get rid of his illogical behaviour and his gibberish posts with multiple typos per word asap.


Time to think about which of my suspects i gonna vote now, maybe even another pops up

Edited 9/22/2014 11:17:16

I did jump on the wagon in a sense that I didn't want to be first. But I have been voicing concern about bdh1998 for awhile, so there's hardly no reasoning.

I vote bdh as i agree with most of previous argument.

Timi is doing good work hunting for scum and didn't put rento on his list of suspects even though rento is voting for him so Timi goes down as village in my book.

Silver isn't helping town a whole lot but it seems more silver being himself rather than silver being scum. Village for now.

Bdh's bandwagon is chugging along with no real counterwagon forming so I'm not confident he'll flip scum.

@Clav, what do you mean "the safest option" when you vote for HHH? Someone who won't argue against you? My experience with HHH through the years is very little talking and I don't expect it to change in this game tbh so I'm not going to lynch him for being quiet.

@Arun, "I don't want to bandwagon" - then you bandwagon. Why don't you want to bandwagon? If you think he's scum then there's no problem.

@Tactical Incursion, You advocated a multikill. Seriously?

I'm looking forward to Dom's commentary.

@Ace I suggested a multi-kill because I thought HHH would be a waste of a lynch and I thought it would be better to lynch someone more suspicious along with the inactive, versus JUST lynching HHH.

Yeah, that still sounds like very bad reasoning. Unfortunately I don't think there are enough votes remaining to lynch you.

Vote Tactical Incursion

Ace seems very similar in this game to when he was a villager, so I respect his reasoning. And I don't agree much with Tactical or think a multi-lynch would be helpful.

The vote for Tactical is to generate a closer vote than everyone voting one person again like last round as that doesn't really show us too much.

I'm quite worried about Rento's vote though? Why Timi?

Timinator's posts so far seem thoughtful and very useful so I'd really like to hear why he's a suspect?

Edited 9/22/2014 13:02:35

i vote gnuffone becas he hasnt said anything

New suspicions based on votes:

Clavicus and Apollo: Why HHH? He is so silent; I don't understand the point of voting him out when there are others that are more likely to be wolves.

I actually agree with your second sentence, Tbh it wasn't the best option. But at such early times, we are bound to get votes wrong. If hhh dies it will be no big loss, so its my vote because I don't want to risk it on someone else. The more discussion, the more ideas of who the wolves could be.

Silver is good contender wolf for the future, we should seer him later on. However he is not the most obvious for the time being.

For now I suggest we go with rento, he is acting weird by throwing people in to the open straight away. His recent vote and intelligent looking but actually not speech, is another spanner in the works making me belief he is most likely a wolf.

Also for those arguing if I was a wolf firstly if I was a wolf I would not bring argument so early in the game to defend my name. However as I am a villager I am going to argue my innocence till the day I die, which hopefully never comes.

As for todays vote there are a large range of small reasons why various people should be lynched, but no collective to be certain on anyone other then rento as explained and for that reason,

I vote rento

Ace; I don't want to bandwagon because a) it gives you no info on me and b) it may lead you to suspect me.

@Arun, "I don't want to bandwagon" - then you bandwagon. Why don't you want to bandwagon? If you think he's scum then there's no problem.

Ace; I don't want to bandwagon because a) it gives you no info on me and b) it may lead you to suspect me.

So you vote based on a) Not wanting people to have 'info' on you ... interesting choice of words and b) Not wanting to be suspected?

I don't actually think you are a Wolf - what are the odds on pulling that 3 out of 3?

But you don't seem to know how to play as a villager. For one you're voting to try and stay alive. You should be voting to try and kill Wolves. As a villager it doesn't matter if you survive to the end it matters if the village saves itself by killing the Wolves. Your 'life' is not important compared to that. So you should spend your turns playing as a team.

Or we can use the logic so many people used on MMB on you? "He just goes along with everyone else so he's no loss" ...?

Do you think bdh is a wolf? Last time you were chatting you were thinking: Skunk, Me and Silver

Skunk is suspicious for the same reason Ace is. He also disagreed with Rento's fairly reasonable wolf.

You cannot discount Ska and Silver from being wolves together. It's could be a a classic case of them apparently being against each other while actually working together. I think we can expect one or both of them to be a wolf.

What changed your mind? Why is Bdh now a:

Sensible vote

Edited 9/22/2014 18:37:47

Vote: HHH

Reason: Bandwagoning without reason and the only one who might come into a heads-up with bdh which could give info to us

My feeling is still that bdh or silver is a wolf. I hate to jump on the badwagon here, but there seems to be some inertia going for bdh, so that is the way I'm going to vote, (but I would prefer to have one or both of them seered instead). I know I said this before, but if we do lynch bdh and find out he is a wolf, LAWLZ MUST BE NEXT. We all know that Lawlz is the worst bluffer in the world (sorry, buddy!) and we gotta remember how quickly he jumped on bdh's side in the bdh vs. silver thing (even though he has been subtly trying to moderate his position since then). Just my thoughts as of now...

I refer you to Dr. Stupid, Ska.

Ska don't bother trying to put one over me about MMB. He doesn't just go along with everyone; he goes along with the exposed wolves!

So rather than answer any questions you just say ... well someone else did it ... actually isn't that why you thought killing the seer was ok? To be honest that proves my point about you bandwagoning.

Oh and it's an impossibility to go along with exposed wolves because the only time you know for sure they are wolves is when they errr die. And dead people can't talk. So try and talk some sense ey? :)

Edited 9/22/2014 19:33:05

You saw in the last game that Bdh was a 99% wolf.

Gonna vote HHH here. Maybe well get him talking.

Would have liked to maybe vote Eliza but it would be a wasted vote now.

Keep talking village.

I agree with his balls. Eliza is on my enlarged list of suspects