Good questions, AWESOMEGUY.
To answer your questions in order:
- Yes, the winner may do as he/she wishes with the membership. I will award it as the winner wishes.
- The reason we have 4 judges is to try to cut down on bias. (Ties are not considered. It is the average of the scores the judges award.) I myself will be amongst the judges judging the roleplay to ensure that it's fairly done. I also have other security measures in place.
- There will indeed be a set criteria which is a standard to which most role players play by. Of course there's different types, but the criteria stands to include all of them. It will not be revealed since if it was, obviously everyone would try to stick 100% to it which isn't the point.
I'd like to point out that I appreciate questions like this. If anything is ever unclear, I would love to clarify.