Ace Windu is a witch. I checked on him this night. His voting for Little Blue seemed so fishy so I checked him out. I also checked someone else, but I wont reveal him yet for his own protection, since he was a villager.

Town, now go and vote on AceWindu. By the end of the day you will see I was right.

Also, I know we agreed on me not voting first this day, but since i scried a witch and our hero is dead, it is the better way for us to have me vote first, now and from now on to all eternity.

Edited 12/23/2014 17:37:26

Actually I could reveal the other villager, since our hero is dead and littleblue is a cleared villager.
Would be two cleared villagers and the town will be one step ahead all the time.
Thoughts?

Yeah, with the hero dead, it's best for you to vote first.

I'm still confused about only getting one seer message though, if you had two scrys, why didn't we hear about the second or the other seer's actions? Does scrying a villager not trigger a message?

I don't know if we should reveal the other villager yet, it would make it easier for the witches to find our other seer. You could always reveal them if they were being targeted, or if you lost your night protection.

Vote: Ace Windu

Edited 12/23/2014 17:40:53

Yes, the other seer scried two villagers and i scried villager and seer.
Scrying a villager gives no report.
And yes, I had the same thoughts about revealing or not LittleBlue. I am thinking to release my information so the other seer knows who is cleared. If we are lucky we have 4 cleared villagers already. With that information he can decide if its good to come out or not. But yes, I can still release them once the witches steal the first vote.

Revealing or not:

PRO:
- More cleared villagers, for the village to know.
- Ability for the other seer to coordinate better, or perhaps come out and reveal his findings

CONTRA
- More cleared villagers. for the witches to know.
- Likelihood increased for the witches to strike at the other seer.

Edited 12/23/2014 17:52:39

I'm suspicious of A Talking Fan as well, throwing us into a three-way tie was such a bad move.

Yepp. He is on my suspects list as well. I didnt check into him, because I wanted to cover as much ground with scries as possible. I affiliated him with AceWindu, so he is a prime suspect. But maybe we get more solid information later on.

Let's see. ?'s until we have you actually confirmed :D

Ace Windu (Witch?)
Myhandisonfire (Seer?)
Little Blue (Villager)

Arun
A Talking Fan
Dom365
Dr. Stupid
GeneralGror
John Smith
Kellen the Conquerer
Mayor Sonnen
Mr. Fall
Seahawks

Assuming 4 unknown witches, they would have a one-in-six chance of finding the other seer this next night. If you reveal, that goes to one-in-five. Still not great odds.

You have one cleared villager, the other seer has two. That should mean we're very close to knowing who everybody is, so I do think it would be best if you revealed them, but I'd like input from others.

Edited 12/23/2014 17:52:56

There is 13 players left so there is 1 in 13 chance of finding a witch

Ok, I agree with myhand taking first vote from now on (even though he is pretty high up my suspect list). I'm going to follow myhand on the ace windu thing, but understand this... If Ace is not a witch, I will cast every remaining vote I have against myhand.

oops.

Vote: Ace Windu[/]


*also, it was nice knowing you, Little Blue. Gg

yeah, no point in outing villager because myhand can just out tomorrow, if he outs today that villager will die. I still think its dr stupid, but no sufficient proof, other than him being stupid, hence his name.
Vote: Ace Windu

Edited 12/23/2014 21:20:25

Let the fate of Ace wind be sealed

Vote : Ace Windu

I told you guys about mmb as a suspect early game. Witch or not we've always taken him down early game and I'm surprised we didn't this time

Vote: Ace Windu

Fairly easy vote; we've either got a witch in Ace, or a witch in myhand.



I agree that myhand should get the first vote each time from now on, since I think it was likely we started with two heroes; it would be too much of a risk to not allow him the protection.


I also think myhand should hide the villagers names for now; it would solely give the witches targets right now.

Vote Ace Windu

Pretty clear. Bear in mind Ace could bus... but yeah only feasible vote right now. The bus is feasible because Ace appears to be inactive anyway. Just bear that in mind. Why did you seer Ace, Myhand? Seems pointless to me.

Edited 12/23/2014 23:07:59

VOTE ACEWINDU

I haven't checked up on all the reading until now and I won't (too much of a dialog between dr stupid and myhand).

If you are a seer, keep the info to yourself unless the person is at risk of being lynched.

Who is mmb?

watch as ace and myhand are both maf, and she is outing him to make her look more like a seer

Already said that Seahawks ;)

Voting for Ace Windu