<< Back to Warzone Classic Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 20 of 26   1  2  Next >>   
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 10:17:05

Fizzer 
Level 64

Warzone Creator
Report
Hello!

Every week we vote on 5 maps, and the map with the most votes becomes the map of the week for the following week.

Go here to vote: https://www.WarLight.net/MapOfTheWeek/View?Week=6

You can use this thread to discuss the current vote. Tell us why you voted the way you did!
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 10:41:49


Thomas 633
Level 56
Report
hmmm
i did just make one
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 10:49:28

The Glorious Koala
Level 60
Report
Uhm, there are still 2 maps to be determined?
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 10:52:46


Thomas 633
Level 56
Report
yeah

when I made mine it was five
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 11:23:53


Riveath
Level 59
Report
Breaking Green is my pick. Both fun and really visually appealing map. +, I helped testing it ;)
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 11:44:36


Master Ryiro 
Level 63
Report
Battle Island 5 was my pick :) thanks for voting for it

Imperium Romanum this time,its a very balanced map
although i don't like luck associated with the template,0 luck games are good
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 14:09:47

Hennns
Level 60
Report
This one is even, All maps have more than 4 on average rating. I suspect Breaking Green and Imperium Romanum will be 1st and 2nd though :p
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 14:35:44


Riveath
Level 59
Report
Hennns is right, the other 3 are just too big to make auto-game on them ^
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 14:42:51


TBest 
Level 60
Report
1. Imperium Romanum (Has 2 152 ratings, and as such clearly most played.)
2. - 4. Toss Up.


P.S I voted for Breaking Green
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 15:04:49

An abandoned account
Level 56
Report
Don't vote based on what you want as an auto-game. I know he made the boot time way too short last week, but Fizzer has to alter the template. If he doesn't realise that this time round, that's his own silliness. Players make their own games on Map of the Week with better settings anyway.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 18:08:22


ChrisCMU 
Level 61
Report
I love the map of the week idea, but why do maps that don't get voted stay in the following week? Seems like it will takeforever to get some good maps in there if the changeover is so low
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 20:38:58


[NL] Willem van Oranje
Level 57
Report
I voted again for Switzerland, I love that map. Althought the Indian Ocean seems a very solid map to play. Imperium Romanum is very popular but I think that map is too simple to play. Breaking green is visually the best map, but the connections aren't always clear to see.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 21:40:35

An abandoned account
Level 56
Report
@Chris, it's a fair system for the 2nd place map to appear again next week. Think how easy it is for the vote to become split if there's 2 similar maps. Say the final result was:

Map A 40%
Map B 35%
Map C 18%
Map D 4%
Map E 3%

But let's say that most of Map C voters prefer Map B to Map A. If Map C wasn't there and there was less popular Map F in place of Map C, then the results might look like this:

Map A 40%
Map B 52%
Map D 4%
Map E 3%
Map F 1%

So depending on what 3rd to 5th was, the order of the top 2 can easily change. I think it would be better if we ranked the maps in order of preference 1to5 in an AV system rather than the map that comes 2nd getting to come back next week.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-14 21:48:26


eliod 
Level 59
Report
I voted for my Rise and Fall of the Roman Empire of course :-)

But to be true... There is no chance for the map to reach the 1st, 2nd or even 3rd place.
So everyone, who would choose my map: Take Breaking Green!

· overwhelming Artwork
· much fun playing
· it's worth it
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-16 02:30:14


John Smith
Level 59
Report
Maybe, you could make the voting for the map of the week preference voting. That way, it would be slightly more accurate, and the case Clement Attlee outlined above won't happen.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-16 15:14:12


ChrisCMU 
Level 61
Report
Yeah, I would rather see a threshold for 2nd place. What if 2nd place gets %7 of the vote? Why bring it back?

What if 1,2,3 are 30, 28, 27? Why not bring back 3rd? That map is out forever despite being 3 % points out of first

Edited 2/16/2015 15:15:57
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-16 19:43:30


Windows 10
Level 58
Report
Building on John Smith's suggestion, here is an alternative voting scheme (called the Borda count): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borda_count

That way we avoid most situations discussed above whereby the introduction of new maps can skew the outcome of the vote. It also helps for the case where you have more than one map you like in a given week, since you vote not for one map, but rather choose an ordering of all five maps.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-16 21:57:04


buddyboyb1
Level 56
Report
I like Breaking Green and Imperium Romanum both, but I have only played Breaking Green once so I voted for Imperium Romanum.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-16 22:48:40


Riveath
Level 59
Report
I think either Breaking Green or Imperium Romanum win that.
Map of the week discussion: Week 6: 2015-02-17 13:44:26


Ranek
Level 55
Report
Instead of which map you guys prefer, I would really like to know why you prefer the map youve voted.
Posts 1 - 20 of 26   1  2  Next >>