If that is correct, that means:

A Talking Fan - Was the robber. Is now a villager
Ace Windu - Seer
Apollo - Villager, who may actually be a werewolf
Coaleyes - Doppelganger, now troublemaker
Forbidden Knowledge - claims wolf, likely tanner or minion
Genghis - was villager, is now robber
his balls. - troublemaker
myhandisonfire - Villager, but maybe a werewolf
skunk940 - Villager, but maybe a werewolf
Traintown - Villager

Spares - Drunk, Werewolf, Villager

Myhand, Ace claims to have seen 2 of the spare cards, not people.

I dont understand? What do you mean by spare cards?

I read it again, now that is making things complicated.
Ace did you purposely check the spare cards?

I'd guess he did. That's what I was planning on doing if I ended up being the seer.

may I ask by what logic?

More information.

How is that more information?
That is wasting a more than 25% chance to win the game right there.

how do you figure 25%? After all, if he did see a werewolf, there is only 1 werewolf in play, making it 10%.

17 more hours btw guys...at least according to the internet XD

Notice how his balls and myhand have both attempted to stall for time.... knowing we have a tight schedule to make decisions -.-

I am voting skunk.

I'm leaning in that direction at the moment too...but everything is so unclear right now. We need more input.

If coaleyes was the doppleganger she can just confirm me.

Myhand. Looking at the spare cards can be very useful. You wait for a fake claim.

We know there are only three villagers in play yet by my reconing 5 players claim to have started as one. What's the deal there? In addition ace claims one of the villagers is spare. What a mess!

It's possible ace is wolf and saw seer card so has claimed that.

Oh and the hunter thinks he's village. So we can say there are 4 villagers in play with one in the spare pile.

So either two of the claimed villagers are lying.
Or ace is lying.
Don't really want to go near forbidden knowledge.

A talking fan is telling the truth which clears ghengis I think.

So two from Apollo myhand skunk and traintown were originally lying. One is wolf, one is minion.

I switched traintown and talking fan so even if TT was lying he is now a villager and talking fan is the wolf. So train town if you started a wolf and were lying tell us now please and we lynch talking fan. If not you are both cleared.

If that is the case it leaves just two from three in my opinion. Apollo myhand and skunk

And of course ace lying is an option.

So those mentioned above. Got any ideas how we can figure this all out?

Skunk has been trying very hard to put suspicion on others. I'll probably vote there at this point.

I did not start wolf. I started villager

Coaleyes is a minion and forbidden is a tanner. Your basing this argument on the fact Coaleyes is telling the truth!

1) I admit to my mistake

2) Yes I was the Doppelganger

3) Yes I looked at His Balls role

4) Yes I swapped Talking Fan and Genghis

5) Hopped we would both claim the same role

6) His Balls took ages to claim


@His Balls sorry to take ur turn 4 you



Also back to the seer we cannot say that the drunk role wasn't in play at night.

And that's a risk especially if the drunk turned wolf.

Also is it safe to presume one wolf role is in play?