Review by
Nathan on 6/11/2014.
Incredible map! So many maps of Middle Earth could use the terrain far more effectively - this one really does so. The scale is grand and the battles are glorious.
My only substantive (as opposed to aesthetic) comment is that the northern wastelands should probably connect down to Angband and/or eastern Ard-Galen, just even things out a bit.
Cosmetically, some of the borders make it hard to see how territories connect. Also, Woods (4) in the Beleriand Coast probably should not connect to Plains (13) in the West Beleriand Plains. Finally, I would love to see each territory receive a unique name - so many are called something like "Hills (1)" or "Marshes (3)". Still - a fantastic job!
4 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
Barad Khazad! Khazad Aimenu! Excelent map, faithfully recreates the setting of the Silmarillion and of the early legends of Middle Earth.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Review by
Timothy Rosini on 12/11/2015.
Big Silmarillion fan here, this was a joy to play. Maybe tries to encompass a bit much but nonetheless I thoroughly appreciate the meticulous detail and time that went into creating this map. Thank you.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Review by
Jiror on 6/11/2014.
Estolad Fortress is untagetable, as it is placed beneath south estolad. if this is fixed it would be a decent map
Response by map creator
Imperator on 6/11/2014
Since this is a pretty major screw up, I've fixed this and submitted a new version right away :) Hopefully you weren't too pissed off and you can find it in your heart to give me another chance(This is my first map).
EDIT: The New version has gone public, so this issue should be fixed now :)
2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
Review by
Matt Schwartz on 7/31/2024.
NO CHANGE
0 out of 0 people found this review helpful.