Sorry it took so long to reply. If it's a post I have to sit down and think about, I usually need a quiet space and time to contemplate, so I push it off until such a time arrives.
But what about freedom? Shouldn't we have the freedom to choose?
What is freedom? Neitzsche's definition is probably the closest to ideal freedom (from a modern standpoint), but far from practical. Freedom is, in a sense, the absence of responsibility
and dependence towards anyone,
except yourself. You are born and raised until you've come of an age where you are self-sufficient. Then what? That's 16-22 years where you've been living off your parents and tax payers. Nothing comes free, don't be fooled into thinking otherwise. You are dependent on the community - as much as it's dependent on you. When there's a threat to the community, you should know how to defend it, that's the limitation to anyone individual's freedom, be it democracy or dictatorship.
If the government trains us in self defense, why not open a self-defense class?
Self-defense in the military is 1. Specialized, 2. Professional and 3. Not "just a Hobby" Going to kick-boxing class 2 times a week may teach you how to fight and keep you fit, but actual training takes complete focus and rigor. That means putting everything else on hold - family, career, your dreams - to focus on this one thing. That's why conscripts get sent to barracks, separated from civilians.
And if everyone has the same level of fighting skill, wouldn't it render your army training useless?
Going to the military isn't all about learning how to fight. It's about learning how to function as a unit. Take orders, respond to emergency situations and react under pressure. Conscripts that go into the workforce are some of the most professional men and women out there. Of course you hear stories about military dad's who are alcoholics and abusive, but there are those who never stepped foot on a base and are like that or worse. In fact, being a drunk women-beater in the US military can get you a court martial - that's military court, not a jury of civilian peers.
Just because everyone can fight, doesn't mean their training is useless, because learning how to fight changes you from the inside as well. Confidence, responsibility, resourcefulness, goal-orientation - these are all skills conscripts learn and use for the rest of their lives.