@Ox
We cannot retrospectively remake all those games. GE stating that Koala is MIA isn't enough. We'll use the date you notified Pushover, and by that date, only the game against VS in Great Lakes will be remade.
@ let's fight
Tbh I still dont like this replacement rule. At least not how it is now. It makes more problems than it solves.
Also
Clans with retired players get a second Chance, actually okay. But to at least the same conditions? If not even improved conditions?
-There is no deadline for calling their substitute. Or?
-Do they really get 2 chances for a win (like 'first it is tried with an AI to win and if it doesnt work we know how our opponent plays and we can try with a substitute', come on really?)
-By the first game opponents stretagy can be tested, like mentioned above, and that not by watching history of past games.
They don't get "two chances" as you put it. Only games(not past pick stage) after the notification will be remade. I think the confusion here is due to the declaration being made in private in some cases(which could have been avoided). This is why we request that such declarations are made in this thread henceforth. I think Memele has provided a clear explanation of how these cases are being handled.
@Don
We completely agree with what you're saying. We already have a solution to the problem next season. However, we're interpreting current rules(from the end of CL7) as best as we can. I'd like to point out that it is impossible to come up with a comprehensive rule set which covers every situation. Every player in the league is welcome to ask for more clarification on the ruleset at the start of a season. However, from time to time there will be ambiguity in the wording of a rule and we'll have to judge on a case-by-case basis.
Edited 8/5/2016 21:07:36
