Chris please take over cl again

One thing I haven't seen is any suggestions on how to manage possible boots in the future.

But Ekstone posted an idea earlier that has been discussed within our clan before.

I for one think all division A clans should be banned, for taking too long in CL.

I understand that some people like Ethics Committee decision, some not, but for sure we have advantages:

1. Violations are resolved by authorized body and sanctions declared;
2. Precedents for understanding rules and possible change of rules were created.

Thanks for the above. Now lets move on. Yes, some clans have suffered, but I am sure they have resources to move forward.

Chris please take over cl again

Do you think Chris would be any less harsh? Heheh.

For years, WG was the Stannis Baratheon of the Warzone community.

I prefer Ned Stark. We don't worship crazy red haired women. Lol

Skyrim belongs to the Nords!


...

Not the correct North, oops.

When will the ethics committee review the 101st/Apprentice clans in terms of promotions?

When will the ethics committee review the 101st/Apprentice clans in terms of promotions?

You were around when this was discussed, while setting up the structure of CL leadership. And it is and was common sense (and you agreed, as far as I know), that this exactly is not task of the ethics committee!

I also do not get a single bit, what you want to review here, as 101st and Apps have promoted from C to B without cheating, at least I am not aware of any.

Edited 11/21/2018 10:23:47

So who's going to review that issue? TBest? We both know he's not going to make a judgement on that, didn't he say he just wants to keep the league running but not have a input on such "controversial matters".

Also you know what I want reviewed here, I don't want a division A of 101st/Lynx so I think 101st shouldn't be allowed to promote to A.

So essentially, there's been no review on this issue at all.

That's how it was set up. Ethics panel deals with rule breakings, but improvements/rule changes for the future go through TBest.

Christmas keeps on giving. (we aren't even in December yet)

@TBest What time during Christmas are you going to gift us the decision?

Edited 11/21/2018 12:32:09

worship crazy red haired women

Welp, too much TV series, not enough books.

Who is the MVP of cheating? Will Ethics panel give a trophy for this?

You're assuming a so-called student clan can even generate the skill needed to get into A! Challenge accepted.

It wouldn't be an issue at all if our competition was good enough to prevent us from getting there ;)

What happens if lynx demotes?
Do they stay in A because 101st is in B? Does 101st drop down to the qualifiers? What if lynx demotes and 101st promotes? Can lynx claim 101sts spot? Does 101st hold precedence in A until they demote? What constitutes two clans not being able to play together? If a clan ends the promotion process do they both get allowed to be in the same division. What if two clans allow travel freely between the two clans?

This opens up a Pandora's box of questions. Can we really answer them all?

i'd say feeder clans can't be in same division to prevent any fraudulent games. its not a punishment, but a preventative measure, that one should expect when joining a "feeder" clan. it's obviously not the same thing as the mother clan, (Lynx steals away many of the best 101st, Masters steal away many of the best at App) and shouldn't be allowed to compete on the same stage imo

To answer that we need an ethics panel. To prevent prejudice of that ethics panel we need a panel to control the ethics panel. I'd call them useless panel 2.0

Who's gonna audit the audit panel though?

i think everyone would be happier with an audience between all of those involved, easier to come to an agreement