<< Back to Clans Forum   Search

Posts 201 - 220 of 793   <<Prev   1  2  3  ...  6  ...  10  11  12  ...  25  ...  39  40  Next >>   
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 09:42:30


Banana 
Level 61
Report
@Riya, thats not right, because desi is participating in 3 tournies. 1 1v1 and 2 2v2 tournies. So if he won all his games in those, we would lose 60 points. Then its to consider he don't win everything, but still alot of points will be gone.

@Those who mean the clans who lost to desi should get the points - I my opinion they don't deserve them, simply because they didn't win them. I think best solution (IF you are to take our points) is to abandon all his games, and take away the points for those who won to him aswell.

Edited 7/10/2014 09:43:06
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 10:56:19


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
I agree with Fridge and not Pushover - it's a clear rule break that doesn't require much consideration.

And I also agree with Bananashake. Don't gift a team for someone else's rule break. Just penalise the rulebreaker.
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 11:33:32


Waka 
Level 58
Report
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Viz3GlgloChi50YIkMjUsU30xuOTfmd1icPsNrgc8FI/edit#gid=0

updates group B: 55,84% compeleted
clan   score   win%  1v1 win%  max points finished games
20     112     74%   67%       206        43
WarL.   54     55%   47%       200        29
French  63     54%   67%       180        37
VIW     57     47%   43%       179        36
XCD     51     42%   45%       168        38
REGL    51     41%   42%       163        39
BIA     39     33%   36%       157        36

20 is clear in front of all other clans like expected. Behind them WarLighters managed to take the second place for now in win% but since they still are a few games behind in total their score is lower then some others below them


Group C: 70,56% completed
clan   score   win%  1v1 win%  max points finished games
Blitz  137     78%   71%       206        50
Lynx    93     68%   61%       201        41
SNinja  82     59%   63%       179        44
Turtle  94     57%   57%       169        49
BR      91     57%   66%       165        49
Swirve  23     14%   14%        96        50
Ohms    22     16%   18%       122        43

Blitz is still in front of Lynx but the case desi can change some things in the score considering desi has taken 26 points in total for Blitz so far.

Strat 1v1 2-3
Strat 2v2 3-0
2v2 Szeurope 2-0
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 14:58:47


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
Go Warlighters! Give the Frenchies a shock!
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 19:56:46


Master Turtle 
Level 62
Report
Note: Icelandic Turtles are in second!!!
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:03:47


Master Turtle 
Level 62
Report
@Banannashake: If all of his games are abandoned it isn't fair to take away from the points that we received from beating him. It would be the same thing if we beat another blitz player.
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:06:54


Wenyun 
Level 60
Report
I think best solution (IF you are to take our points) is to abandon all his games, and take away the points for those who won to him aswell.

Excluding Blitz, there is currently no difference between abandoning and auto-losing all of Desi's games. The rankings are based on raw score, so the only difference between giving everyone a free win and abandoning is that Blitz will be slightly less behind in the latter scenario. (That, and in the latter scenario, the maximum number of points becomes lower and more confusing.)

I my opinion they don't deserve them, simply because they didn't win them.

On the other hand, those who fairly won the points don't deserve to lose them simply because someone else wasn't following the rules. Personally, I think it's better to give points to those who lost because at least they played by the rules.
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:11:29


Master Turtle 
Level 62
Report
On the other hand, those who fairly won the points don't deserve to lose them simply because someone else wasn't following the rules. Personally, I think it's better to give points to those who lost because at least they played by the rules.

I totally agree Riyamitie!
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:12:55


Banana 
Level 61
Report
If all of his games are abandoned it isn't fair to take away from the points that we received from beating him.

If they are abandoned, it would be the same as if they were never played. = You wont get those points.

It would be the same thing if we beat another blitz player.

No, because vs another blitz player, the game wouldn't be abandoned.

Thats just the fair and logic way of seeing it. Personally I don't care how many points you get.

@Banannashake

Bananashake* :)

Edited 7/10/2014 20:13:52
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:25:02


Darkpie 
Level 61
Report
auto-losses in all games is unfair to players who won against him. not counting any of his games is also unfair to them + It's not a punishment for either Desi or Blitz, except maybe for Desi's stats (Now a wellknown alt so why would MoD care?)

The points of those who won and lost shouldn't be changed. The clans who had future games against Desi could get 1/3 or 1/2 of the points they could have gotten if they won those games (or something like that).

This is just a suggestion if Miyagi & crew decides to punish Blitz in some way cause it would smallen the gap a little bit. It would also allow the league to continue with a realistic pointdistribution. But personally I don't mind either way since I'm not in that league.

Edited 7/10/2014 20:34:17
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 20:26:20


Master Potato
Level 59
Report
Its master shake
Clan League #5: 2014-07-10 21:14:48


Jefferspin 
Level 62
Report
Don't you steal my name for him Spudz! Don't you do it!
Clan League #5: 2014-07-11 11:22:46


Waka 
Level 58
Report
@turtle: yea you were second with total points on that point but if you look carefully you can see it's ordered on win% and with that you were tied with BR on the moment for 4th and i could even have put you below BR but your max points and total points were higher
Clan League #5: 2014-07-11 23:02:15

Widzisz 
Level 62
Report
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0Arn0ahIN9qcsdDM2VU9mUnFONmltYjN1ZlBWTDlXV3c&gid=2

I think "Points Assigned" (Total) does not include last 3vs3 tournament.
Clan League #5: 2014-07-12 00:09:16


ChrisCMU 
Level 61
Report
Ineffable has been pretty busy the last few days.
Clan League #5: 2014-07-13 17:00:58


Master Turtle 
Level 62
Report
Any word from TWM?
Clan League #5: 2014-07-15 13:16:37


Waka 
Level 58
Report
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Viz3GlgloChi50YIkMjUsU30xuOTfmd1icPsNrgc8FI/edit#gid=0

updates group B: 62,34% compeleted
clan   score   win%  1v1 win%  max points finished games
20     120     76%   68%       206        45
WarL.   60     56%   50%       197        32
French  70     55%   66%       177        40
VIW     57     43%   40%       165        40
BIA     61     41%   44%       148        46
XCD     54     40%   45%       157        42
REGL    55     40%   39%       153        43

20 is clear in front of all other clans like expected. Behind them WarLighters managed to take the second place for now in win% but since they still are a few games behind in total their score is lower then some others below them


Group C: 73,16% completed
clan   score   win%  1v1 win%  max points finished games
Blitz  146     79%   71%       206        52
Lynx    96     69%   62%       201        42
BR      95     58%   66%       165        50
SNinja  82     57%   63%       170        46
Turtle  94     56%   56%       166        50
Swirve  31     17%   14%        92        53
Ohms    22     16%   18%       114        45


waiting for the desi-mod judgement to say anything about changes in this group but it's looking pretty solid for Blitz and Lynx considering their win%
Clan League #5: 2014-07-17 01:44:29


Kenny • apex 
Level 59
Report
Since Ineffable seems to be out I have made a replica spreadsheet which took me quite some time and still isn't formatted perfectly, however it should work for now. I'll work on replicating "Player Statistics" later and play on adding functions for recurring players over multiple seasons.. anyways

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_HlNhRewdI3LBc81QSrsOOOSXmHxEkf5KTMNQPg4r28/edit#gid=168045224

Group A: 59.09% completed

Clan  Points    Win%  Max Points
Apex    101    83.78%    221
WG      100    73.17%    205
WM      74     65.71%    202
GG      62     45.24%    164
AHoL    40     30.77%    152
101st   24     22.22%    144
MASTER  41     30.23%    141
Clan League #5: 2014-07-17 06:32:35


Mirror 
Level 60
Report
You now... we are lagging after you, so why update :)
Clan League #5: 2014-07-17 09:10:25


Waka 
Level 58
Report
@lolo: think you are missing 1 game for a player since i get in my sheet on 59,09% if i get rid of 3 players with a game which is 1,5 game but you can't play a game on your own

edit: your problem is that Julkorn of GG has 1 win and 4 losses while he only has 3 losses

this might be some sums to help you automate the sheet so you only have to concentrate on wins and losses.
for points assigned you might be able to use "=sum((D4+E4)*3)"
for max points you might use "=sum((6-E4)*3)"

Edited 7/17/2014 18:48:18
Posts 201 - 220 of 793   <<Prev   1  2  3  ...  6  ...  10  11  12  ...  25  ...  39  40  Next >>