Hm...new idea...is stupid...that's the first time i have ever heard of this but ok :)
I was just trying to put a different perspective on possible solutions instead criticizing all the given ones. The path to the right solutions is to give new ideas all the time. If u allow your self to criticize then u must give some alternative proposal just saying u like or don't like something is not helpful in anyway (not mention counter productive). In didn't say this should be the icons i said maybe we should head in that direction - a simpler more symbolic icon (i'm still for keeping and using the WL logo as i mentioned earlier}.

And a word to Fizzer "design by committee" always and i mean always results in something ugly, so don't mind the critics and comments of all, including me (everyone has a different taste and opinion in what is good and not that doesn't mean they are right, in fact they are probably wrong) just use the icon u feel is best and end this thread.

incaman, people went in your direction. nobody said your input was stupid. your english reading comprehension is at fault here.

Incaman definitely is showing off his great design skills. I sent him an e-mail.

Meanwhile, Huruey has taught me how to make globes! Thanks Huruey!

I created something a lot like what he made so I can play with variations. #9 would be an Android icon since it has no background (an iOS version of this one would be the globe with a frame and background)

I really like 7 for Apple products and 9 for Android. The white territories work way better IMO.

I agree ^^^

I like 9

Personally i still like the black territory but maybe a globe with the color scheme of number 6 for ios and number 9 for android. ( but hey dont listen to me im problably wrong:) )

I like the globe shape, but I still think there needs to be a more defined attack arrow.

Also, I'd like to see how the territory looks next to the gray background on iOS. Might need a black shadow around the globe.

9 for android, Incaman's first design for iOS.

i like 9 for ios, and 8 for android, or maybe the other way around?

I agree with Chris about the attack arrow.
A hybrid of Incaman's with 7 and 9 would look best imo.

I'm in agreement with Frank.

I'm joining team globe for android.

whatever you decide on, for brand continuity I would definitely use the same style for both ios and android.

On a large scale like on the home page the flat images are better suited but on the really small scale mobile device the Globe (#9) looks a lot more sexy and sharper. Clear background for android and coloured background for ios
or both

I agree with Frank.

I believe putting an hybrid of incaman's arrows on 7 and 9 will work.

I believe the one on the right gives a more aesthetically pleasing. The one on the left looks like something from the early 2000's. I would go with the one on the right just make it a full map.

Got the first word, mind as well get my last say in.
I think 6 & 7 are the most appealing,
I do however. Want to cast my vote for a Simple "WL" logo
If not only to create brand recognition, and assist people in remembering and coming back to WL because its familiar and friendly to them.
The globe just seems out of style with the flow of the game, and I know you have been considering it.
Just go for it, and stop stressing yourself out Randy.
We will support you no matter what you choose.

I personally want you to keep the current one.