Train - your analysis is too number dependent. Your list of suspects is based largely on those who posted the least and those who voted the same as another player. You're looking at quantity over quality, in other words.
However, your list of top suspects shares a number of similarities.
Dr Stupid:
Landalf bdh
Gror:
Landalf JohnSmith Kellen Coaleyes
Train:
A Talking Taco bdh1998 Landalf Coaleyes Mr. Pride John Smith Green Frankdeslimste
Common Names:
Landalf Coal Eyes Bdh John Smith
There's a couple other names I would add, namely Arun supporters who suddenly went quiet. If what Pride observed before stands, it would make sense that wolves would support the one spreading chaos like free candy and then slink into the silence as soon as villagers start catching on, very wolf-like indeed.
My top (former supporters of the tyrant Arun) suspects:
Because Coaleyes may be a seer, and has voted for you twice, indicating that you may be a wolf? You're near the bottom of it, because Coaleyes being a seer is pretty unlikely. That's part of why he is so much higher.
Taisho, I agree that it is highly number dependent, but numbers tend to be a better summary of what is actually going on than guesses or, in many cases, intuition. For example, noting that wolves may try to stay invisible and not throw any suspicion on themselves, as well as noting that in order to counteract that, wolves may be far more outspoken than others, is a good reason to be suspicious of the people who post few times or many more times than others. I am in no way guaranteeing that this is the way it is working out, and I have less information than most of you because I do not know how people have acted in previous rounds. This is just my thoughts on who is most likely to be wolves.
That does make it look a little less likely...I was going to go through and read all the messages tonight and come to further conclusions to post. Just didn't have time with all the stuff I did for the first post. I think it is much more likely that he is a wolf and just has a vendetta against you.
Traintown you break my heart trying to pin me down as a wolf. But I guess, there some logic behind... If I were one of you I would think the same... Gror made a list and now he is dead... who were on the list?:
JohnSmith Kellen Landalf Coaleyes
However, I will disagree with list.. I still working out my suspect list.. and it is becoming more and more difficult to discern, specially when some of participants are not actively involved in the conversations.
So far I have seen three school of thoughts in this forum.. the following criteria is being used to target suspects: 1) school of thought No 1 - Least amount of posts is a wolf (hiding wolf) 2) School of thought No 2 - are stupid comments being posted? do they sound rational? (if yes to stupid comments then he is a wolf) 3) School of thought No 3 - If a player has a lot of votes.. let me vote for him too.... (this is not very smart)
So guys, let's sharpen our minds... because villagers are dying by our own hands... even an angel died... you dont want more specials dying, do you?
I never was a " supporter " of Arun. Of course, I originally fancied the idea of an organized resistance due to this confirmed villager business, his decisions have turned me against his leadership. But, it's highly likely his organized resistance plans are still in motion, or even are working ( considering he's stopped wailing about it ), so +1 for Village on that. Wow, the End Game for this is going to be scary though, what with all the factional warfare...
